Stan Musial was more than the game of baseball, more than any highlight reel could show in 60 seconds. Although it may seem like he was snubbed on Tuesday night, I don't think Stan would have wanted it any other way.
If you haven't taken the time to read Joe Posnanski's blog post on Stan the Man's snub at the All-Star Game, do so:
"Should Have Been the Man"
A quote: "You know who represents the Baseball All-Star Game? That’s right: Stan Musial. And the night should have been about him. It was his town. It was his time. it was his game. There were other terrific Cardinals there — Bob Gibson, Ozzie Smith, Red Schoendienst and so on — and they should have been a bigger part of the night too. But mostly it should have been about Stan the Man, Baseball’s Perfect Knight, who played the game as well and with as much purpose as anyone ever."
While disappointment continues to mount over Stan Musial's very un-Ted Williams-esque salute at the 80th MLB All-Star Game, I can't help but think that maybe FOX and baseball did get it right. That's not easy for me to say, for very rarely does FOX ever get something right, but, upon further review, the tribute to the All-Stars Among Us was a tribute to Stan in many respects. Stan Musial has been a constant standard of class, on and off the playing field. He doesn't seek attention, gaudy trophies, or market himself as a bigger-than-life individual, although he certainly could.
You think about one of the most spited ballplayers in recent memory - Barry Bonds - and look at the traits that make him that way, and Stan Musial is pretty much the opposite of every one of them. That's not to throw Barry completely under the bus, because he is still a human being and does still have qualities that we would consider genuine and humane. Who is more remembered though? Who is the better story? This is what Posnanski is saying in not so many words, but maybe Stan's qualities, the qualities we all hope to achieve throughout the course of our own lives, don't lend themselves to the attention that we were expecting Stan to receive.
What's more, the kind of individual that Musial is doesn't need the gaudy ceremony or prolonged celebration that was expected on All-Star Night. His celebration is a humble one, just like his nature, and the sincere appreciation of those that truly were and are his fans, not those who will never fully realize how great his accomplishments have been, on and off the diamond.
Is recognition for his accomplishments truly what Stan stands for? Stan, the son of a Polish immigrant in Pennsylvania; Stan, who not only served over a year in the Navy in 1945 but who also, during the off-season, "took part in the war effort, working for the American Steel & Wire Co. back in Donora" and, along with some other players, "went on a goodwill trip to the Aleutians to visit the troops" in 1943; Stan, who has constantly made himself available to the St. Louis fans, even as his health declines; Stan, who not only is baseball's "Perfect Knight", but who also is "the embodiment of the American dream."
Rather, I think pairing the recognition of Stan Musial with the recognition of the people that are working to make a positive impact in our communities was the most fitting for such a strong community man. They, after all, are applying the standards that Stan lives by, that Stan applied to his entire baseball career, to the individuals that need a "Perfect Warrior" for them. A ceremony full of pomp and circumstance for Stan would have seemed a little misplaced for a man that doesn't live his life that way. No, he gets it; he gets that his measure isn't defined by what he was able to do on the baseball field, his measure isn't defined by how much he's celebrated individually.
Sure, I would have loved for there to be a video splice highlighting some of Musial's most memorable baseball moments. It could have been relatively short but would have helped relate who he was on the field more aptly with the rest of the world. They could have played some epic music in the background, could have displayed one of baseball true All-Stars in the spotlight. I think that was the main flaw that took place in the pre-game salute.
But, then again, the moment wasn't just about Stan, it was about the way we should live our own lives. I know this may seem sappy, but Stan is a model for what we all should strive to be. Is he perfect? No, of course. Are the people that were highlighted for their work in their communities perfect? No, they aren't either. It is the qualities that they outwardly show, and those that are implied inside, that should really be applauded, respected, followed.
Stan isn't just about baseball, never was, and never will be. On Tuesday night, Stan was juxtaposed with those who have made great sacrifices and showed incredible character to care for those around them. It literally was him, the people, and the President. I can't think of a more powerful tribute to an entire man, not just one part of him. More powerful than a highlight reel, more powerful than a bunch of words that would have just as soon been forgotten.
The night was about Stan Musial, even though we wouldn't deem so from our own expectations. For a humble man who has showed that he was more than just baseball, the night was perfect. In spite of its flaws, through its flaws, it was perfect. For the Perfect Warrior, the Perfect Knight.
Works Cited: Finkel, Jan. "Stan Musial." The Baseball Biography Project.
Keep reading